Pondering fandom...

[cairistiona]

I'm at times amused by fandom, specifically the differences in my two fandoms. In LOTR, the 'good' reviewers tend to leave thoughtful critique, with often genius meta sprinkled in that could pass for collegiate level essay exam answers (complete with documentation).

However, in the Captain America/Marvel fandom, I know I've reached the pinnacle when I get one like this:

          ;_;

Thanks, I really needed heartbreak at work.

You monster. *sobs*

Yep. I've been called a monster. There can be no higher honor. XD

(That was for Orders Acknowledged, which is a bit of a heartrender. They'll probably destroy their computer--or mine--after they read the follow-up story I'm readying to post later this week...)

Comments

[cairistiona7.livejournal.com]

Your reviews are most certainly NOT dire. :) I appreciate each and everyone. I was just making the point that with the Marvel fandom, you usually don't get the long-form reviews like you do with LOTR/Tolkien.

And thank you for recommending my CA stories! I'm glad your friend enjoyed them (does this friend read them online and review or does she just enjoy them anonymously? Wondering if perhaps I'd seen her online name).

[lindahoyland.livejournal.com]

She has reviewed at least one as JuliaAurelia. You are welcome.

[cairistiona7.livejournal.com]

Ooh, yes, she has! :D